Should You Lie in a Police Interview? Why It’s a Dangerous Mistake
Being invited to a voluntary police interview or being arrested is an intimidating experience. The police interview forms the foundation of their case. It allows officers to put allegations directly to you and gives you the chance to respond if you wish to — but what you say is recorded and can become crucial evidence later.
The Importance of Legal Advice Beforehand
Before your interview begins, your solicitor will attend a pre-interview disclosure meeting with the officer in charge. This allows your solicitor to find out more about the allegations so that they can properly advise you. After meeting with you, your solicitor will help you decide whether to:
Answer police questions,
Provide a prepared written statement, or
Remain silent.
This legal advice is vital because mistakes made during the interview can have serious long-term consequences.
Why Lying in a Police Interview is a Serious Risk
When under pressure, some suspects feel tempted to lie in order to protect themselves. However, lying in a police interview is almost always a damaging choice.
Here’s why:
It may damage your credibility – If the police disprove your account, your defence may be undermined in court.
Your solicitor cannot support dishonesty – Solicitors follow strict ethical rules. If you tell your solicitor you intend to lie, they must withdraw from the interview.
Police evidence can catch lies – Modern investigation tools include DNA profiling, CCTV, mobile phone location data, and eyewitness testimony. Lies are easily exposed.
It increases the chance of being charged – Being caught lying can strengthen the case against you rather than weaken it.
Sometimes, the best advice is to say nothing until you and your solicitor have had more time to prepare. A further interview can always be arranged later on.
“On Tape” or Digital — It’s All Recorded
Although interviews used to be recorded on tapes, today they are stored digitally, often in secure police databases. The principle remains the same: every word you say is captured and may be used as evidence.
Don’t Risk It – Defend with a Plan
Lying in a police interview may feel like a quick escape, but it usually makes matters far worse. Instead, take the allegation seriously from the outset. By instructing an experienced criminal defence solicitor, you gain access to expert advice, careful preparation, and a defence strategy designed to protect your future. With the right solicitor, it may even be possible to avoid prosecution altogether.
At Kelly Blake Legal, we are someone you can trust with proven results. We have the experience and track record to guide you through the police interview process with confidence. If you have been invited to a voluntary police interview or are concerned about an allegation, contact us today for confidential and specialist advice.
